Established Representative at the UK Intellectual Property Office — since 2008New scam warning · 12 Nov: RL Law Trademark Notice: A New Law Firm’s Nam…
FeatureTrademark Disputes

Cadbury Purple and the KitKat Shape: The Chocolate Trademark Cases

Jonathan Paton, Founder & CEO7 min read · Last reviewed 4 November 2026

For almost twenty years, Cadbury and Nestlé fought each other in the UK courts over two of the most recognisable things in a sweet shop: Cadbury's purple and the four-finger shape of a KitKat. Add Nestlé's earlier battles with Mars over the Polo mint and "Have a Break", and you have nine UK rulings that between them map out how far a colour, a shape or a slogan can be protected. If your brand depends on how something looks rather than what it's called, these cases are worth knowing before you apply for trademark registration.

The parties
Cadbury and Nestlé
plus Nestlé v Mars
UK rulings
9
2003 to 2022
Courts involved
Court of Justice of the EUCourt of AppealHigh Court
The lesson

A colour or shape can be a trademark. The wording and the evidence decide it.

Who are Cadbury and Nestlé?

Cadbury UK makes Dairy Milk and has used a shade of purple, Pantone 2685C, on its chocolate packaging for decades. Société des Produits Nestlé owns KitKat and Polo. Each opposed the other's attempts to register something that isn't a word: Nestlé opposed Cadbury's purple, and Cadbury opposed Nestlé's KitKat shape. Mars UK opposed Nestlé's earlier applications for the Polo shape and "Have a Break".

The key case: Cadbury's purple refused

Court of Appeal · 2013Claimant won

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

Cadbury's 2004 application described the purple as covering the whole visible surface of the packaging, or being the "predominant" colour on it. The Hearing Officer and the High Court had both accepted it. The Court of Appeal didn't. The word "predominant" meant the mark could take many different visual forms, with other undefined colours and materials alongside the purple, so it wasn't one sign described with enough clarity and precision. Nestlé's appeal was allowed and the application refused.

“What I'd take from this is that a colour can be a trademark. What failed Cadbury was the description, not the purple.”
Jonathan Paton, Founder & CEO

The rulings over time

Each badge describes that one ruling
  1. 2003Nestlé v Mars UK · Court of Appeal"Have a Break" questions sent to EuropeProcedural ruling
  2. 2004Nestlé v Mars UK · Court of AppealPolo shape cannot be amended after filingDefendant won
  3. 2012Nestlé v Cadbury UK · High CourtPurple upheld, but only for milk chocolatePartly successful
  4. 2013Nestlé v Cadbury UK · Court of AppealPurple application refusedClaimant won
  5. 2014Nestlé v Cadbury UK · High CourtKitKat questions sent to EuropeProcedural ruling
  6. 2016Nestlé v Cadbury UK · High CourtKitKat shape refusedDefendant won
  7. 2017Nestlé v Cadbury UK · Court of AppealRefusal upheld on appealDefendant won
  8. 2018Cadbury UK v The Comptroller General · Court of AppealWording cannot be deleted laterDefendant won
  9. 2022Nestlé v Cadbury UK · High CourtPlain purple valid; packaging version notPartly successful

The purple cases

High Court · 2012Partly successful

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

A single colour can be a valid trademark, and the "predominant" wording didn't sink the mark at this stage. But Cadbury's evidence only showed purple identified milk chocolate, so the registration was narrowed to milk chocolate rather than chocolate generally.

Read our summary
Court of Appeal · 2018Defendant won

Cadbury UK v The Comptroller General

Cadbury tried to delete the "predominant colour" wording from an older purple registration, arguing it was really a series of two marks. The court held it was one mark with a vague description, and a registered mark can't be altered like that after the event. The validity of the older mark itself was left open.

Read our summary
High Court · 2022Partly successful

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

Nestlé and Cadbury had settled, but the UK Intellectual Property Office joined the appeal to get the law clarified. The purple described simply as a Pantone colour, in itself, could be a valid sign. The purple described as applied to packaging, without saying how, still couldn't, for the same reason as in 2013.

Read our summary

The KitKat shape

High Court · 2014Procedural ruling

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

Nestlé applied to register the plain four-finger shape, without the embossed name. The court found the evidence showed people recognised the shape and associated it with KitKat, but the test for when a shape becomes distinctive through use was unclear, so it sent questions to the Court of Justice of the EU rather than deciding.

Read our summary
High Court · 2016Defendant won

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

Applying Europe's answer, the evidence showed recognition and association, not that people relied on the shape alone to know who made the bar. Nestlé's appeal was dismissed.

Read our summary
Court of Appeal · 2017Defendant won

Nestlé v Cadbury UK

The refusal was upheld. Despite huge sales, heavy advertising and a survey in which about half of people recognised the shape as a KitKat, the bar was always sold in an opaque wrapper carrying the KitKat name, so shoppers never chose it by shape alone.

Read our summary

What Europe's top court said (September 2015). A shape can become distinctive through use, but the owner has to show that a significant proportion of consumers see the product as coming from one business because of the shape itself, not because of the name or packaging that goes with it.

Before KitKat: Nestlé v Mars

Court of Appeal · 2003Procedural ruling

Nestlé v Mars UK

Nestlé applied to register "Have a Break" on its own, separate from "Have a Break... Have a KitKat". The court agreed the shorter phrase lacked distinctive character in itself, and sent Europe the question of whether use as part of the longer slogan could make the shorter phrase distinctive. In 2005 the Court of Justice said it can, if the shorter phrase on its own identifies the business.

Read our summary
Court of Appeal · 2004Defendant won

Nestlé v Mars UK

Nestlé applied for the plain Polo mint shape, without the embossed name, then tried to add "white" and "standard size" later. That would have changed the mark itself, not just narrowed it, so the amendment wasn't allowed and the 1994 application failed.

Read our summary

What I’d take from the chocolate cases

Jonathan PatonFounder & CEO
  1. 1What I'd take from this is that a colour can be a trademark. What failed Cadbury was the description, not the purple.
  2. 2The description has to show competitors exactly what's protected. Flexible wording like "predominant" or "applied to packaging" reads as vague.
  3. 3You can't rewrite a mark after filing or registration. Adding colour and size to the Polo, or deleting wording from the purple, both failed.
  4. 4Recognition isn't enough for a shape or slogan. Customers have to rely on it alone to know who's behind the product.
  5. 5Fame, sales and advertising help, but they don't replace that test. KitKat had all three.
How we can help

Before you file, a trademark consultation and clearance audit looks at which parts of your brand carry real weight, including colours and shapes. Our trademark registration service drafts the description and specification so it says exactly what you're claiming. For a product's look, design registration is often the better fit, and we can trademark your logo alongside your name, so you're not relying on a colour or shape alone.

For our view on what this means for a smaller business, read The Chocolate Wars: Can You Own a Colour or a Shape?.

Book a free call, email enquiries@thetrademarkhelpline.com or ring 0161 833 5400.

Related questions

This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Case summaries are drawn from published UK judgments; summaries drafted with AI assistance and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Last reviewed 4 November 2026. Report an error.

Trusted by businesses across the UK & beyond
Latest from The Trademark HelplineKnowledge Hub

Book your free 15-minute callChoose a day and time and a specialist will call you.

or call 0161 833 5400

Download Your Guide

Fill in the form below to access your free guide.