Nestlé v Cadbury: High Court sends Kit Kat shape mark questions to the CJEU
Société des Produits NestlévCadbury UK
- Court
- High Court
- Judgment
- 17 January 2014
- Citation
- [2014] EWHC 16 (Ch)
Showing people recognise a shape isn't enough; you need proof they rely on the shape itself to identify the brand.
Nestlé wanted to register the shape of its four-finger Kit Kat bar as a trademark. Cadbury opposed it, and the High Court sent the hardest legal questions to the CJEU rather than deciding the case itself.
What happened
Nestlé applied to register the 3D shape of its four-finger Kit Kat bar, without the embossed words, as a UK trademark for bakery and confectionery goods. Cadbury opposed the application, arguing the shape was not distinctive, had not become distinctive through use, and was simply the shape needed to make the product or achieve a technical result. A hearing officer let the mark through for cakes and pastries but rejected it for everything else. Both Nestlé and Cadbury appealed that split decision to the High Court.

What did the court decide in Société des Produits Nestlé v Cadbury UK?
The judge found the hearing officer had been wrong to treat cakes and pastries differently from the other goods on the question of whether the shape was inherently distinctive (a name, logo or tagline that stands out on its own without needing to be learned). The same reasoning applied across all the goods in the application. On whether the shape had become distinctive through use, the judge agreed with Cadbury that Nestlé had only shown people recognised and associated the shape with Kit Kat, not that they relied on the shape itself to identify where the product came from. Because the legal test for that, and the scope of the rules excluding shapes dictated by the nature of the goods or needed for a technical result, were genuinely unclear under EU law, the judge referred three questions to the CJEU instead of ruling on the case.
What we learned from this
- What I'd take from this is that recognising a product shape and relying on it as a brand indicator are two different things, and this case shows how much that gap matters legally.
- If you're trying to register a shape, logo or tagline as a trademark, evidence that customers simply know it isn't enough on its own.
- Product shape marks face extra hurdles that word or logo marks don't, including exclusions for shapes needed to make the product work.
- A High Court decision isn't always the end of the story. Here it was a staging post, with the real legal test only settled after a reference to a higher court.
Things to be aware of
- This judgment didn't finally decide whether the Kit Kat shape could be registered. It referred the hard questions to the CJEU, so the outcome depended on later rulings.
- The case turned on EU trademark law as it applied to the UK at the time, so it's worth checking how current rules compare before assuming the same reasoning applies today.
- The split outcome (allowed for cakes and pastries, refused for other goods) shows that the same shape can be treated differently depending on the exact goods it's registered for.
The businesses involved
Société des Produits Nestlé SA
The Nestlé group company that holds and manages Nestlé's trademark portfolio, including the application to register the four-finger Kit Kat shape as a UK trademark.
- Note
- Registered outside the UK
Cadbury UK Ltd
Registered in England in 1919 and still active. Based in Birmingham, it makes cocoa and chocolate confectionery and holds a large number of trademarks on the UK trademark register.
- Companies House
- 00155256 Active
- Incorporated
- May 1919
- Registered office
- Birmingham
- Business activity
- Manufacture of cocoa and chocolate confectionery
- UK trademarks
- 958
What happened next
- The High Court's questions were taken up by the CJEU as Case C-215/14, a preliminary reference on the Kit Kat shape mark.Source: Infocuria
- After the CJEU ruling, the dispute returned to the English courts, with the Court of Appeal later hearing further argument on whether the shape could be registered.Source: Wipo
- Trade press later reported that a subsequent UK court ruling found the Kit Kat shape lacked enough distinctiveness to be registered, with Nestlé said to be considering a further appeal.Source: Confectionery News, April 2016
What others said about it
- Gowling WLG's legal update treated the High Court's referral itself as the key event, flagging that the acquired distinctiveness test needed CJEU clarification before the case could move forward.Source: Gowlingwlg, January 2014
How we can help
If something in this case sounds familiar, talk it through with us. The first call is free for new clients.
This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Summary drafted with AI assistance from the published judgment and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Judgment: [2014] EWHC 16 (Ch) on Find Case Law, published under the Open Justice Licence. Company details from Companies House; trademark counts from the UK trademark register. Last reviewed 27 October 2026. Report an error.










