Established Representative at the UK Intellectual Property Office — since 2008New scam warning · 12 Nov: RL Law Trademark Notice: A New Law Firm’s Nam…

Nestle v Mars UK: why you can’t bolt colour and size onto a failed shape trademark

Jonathan Paton
Jonathan Paton, Founder & CEO3 min read · Last reviewed 4 November 2026
Key factsDefendant won

Societe Des Produits NestlevMars UK

Court
Court of Appeal
Judgment
26 July 2004
Citation
[2004] EWCA Civ 1008
The lesson

Define the exact mark, including colour and size if needed, before you file, not after.

View the full case fileThe judgment, documents and timeline, with a free Temmy Portal login

Nestle wanted to register the plain shape of a POLO mint as a trademark, then tried to fix the application later by adding colour and size details. Mars UK won, as the Court of Appeal ruled that sort of late change isn't allowed.

What happened

Nestle applied in 1994 to register the plain three dimensional shape of a POLO mint, without the embossed word POLO, as a trademark for sugar confectionery. Mars opposed the application. The Registrar's Hearing Officer found the shape had only become distinctive when it was white and the standard POLO size, and suggested Nestle amend the application to add those limits. Mars argued this kind of amendment wasn't legally permitted. The High Court agreed with Mars, and Nestle appealed to the Court of Appeal.

Temmy the owl reading

What did the court decide in Societe Des Produits Nestle v Mars UK?

The Court of Appeal dismissed Nestle's appeal. It held that neither section 13 of the Trade Marks Act 1994, which deals with limitations on the rights a registration gives you, nor section 39, which deals with restricting the goods covered or amending an application, could be used to add colour and size to the mark itself. Doing that would change the identity of the mark as originally filed, rather than simply narrowing what it covered. As a result, the original 1994 application, for the unlimited shape, failed, and Nestle had to rely on a fresh application it filed in 2003 instead.

What we learned from this

  • What I'd take from this is that the mark you file is the mark you're stuck with. If a shape, colour or size combination is what actually makes your product recognisable, that's what needs to be in the application from day one.
  • Think carefully before filing a trademark for just the shape of a product. If the shape alone doesn't stand out to customers, the application can fail even if the full look, including colour and size, clearly does.
  • You can usually narrow the goods or services a trademark covers after filing, but you can't use that process to redefine what the mark actually is.
  • If an early application is refused, filing a fresh one with the right details from the start may be the only practical fix, though it means losing the earlier filing date.

Things to be aware of

  • This case is about shape marks specifically. The same reasoning won't automatically apply to every type of trademark dispute.
  • Losing the original filing date matters commercially, because it can let competitors register similar marks in the gap, or build up their own use of a similar look.
  • The ruling doesn't say shape marks can never work. It says the shape alone has to be distinctive on its own if that's all you're registering.

The businesses involved

Claimant

Societe Des Produits Nestle SA

The Nestle group company that holds and manages the group's trademark registrations, including for its confectionery products such as POLO mints.

Note
Registered outside the UK
Defendant

Mars UK Ltd

The Mars UK confectionery business that opposed Nestle's application at the time of this dispute.

What happened next

  • A separate Intellectual Property Office hearing officer decision in opposition proceedings between Nestle and Mars UK recorded that a related Nestle trademark application was opposed on several distinctiveness grounds under section 3(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994.Source: Ipo, May 2002
  • Legal commentary site 5RB later listed the case among notable reported trademark decisions involving Nestle and Mars.Source: 5Rb, July 2005

How we can help

If something in this case sounds familiar, talk it through with us. The first call is free for new clients.

This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Summary drafted with AI assistance from the published judgment and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Judgment: [2004] EWCA Civ 1008 on Find Case Law, published under the Open Justice Licence. Company details from Companies House; trademark counts from the UK trademark register. Last reviewed 4 November 2026. Report an error.

Trusted by businesses across the UK & beyond
Latest from The Trademark HelplineKnowledge Hub
Temmy the owl with a question

Book your free 15-minute callChoose a day and time and a specialist will call you.

or call 0161 833 5400

Download Your Guide

Fill in the form below to access your free guide.