Nestlé v Cadbury: purple colour trademark upheld, but only for milk chocolate
Société des Produits Nestlé S.AvCadbury UK
- Court
- High Court
- Judgment
- 1 October 2012
- Citation
- [2012] EWHC 2637 (Ch)
A colour can be registered as a trademark, but only for the exact goods your evidence actually covers.
Nestlé challenged Cadbury's trademark registration for the colour purple on chocolate packaging, arguing it wasn't a valid sign at all. Cadbury won on that point, but lost ground when the judge narrowed the registration to milk chocolate only.
What happened
Cadbury had registered the colour purple, Pantone 2685C, as a trademark covering various chocolate products, describing it as applied to the whole or predominant colour of the packaging. Nestlé opposed the registration. A hearing officer allowed most of the application to stand, so Nestlé appealed to the High Court. Nestlé argued the mark wasn't a valid "sign" capable of being represented graphically, and separately that the list of goods it covered was too broad given the evidence Cadbury had actually put forward.

What did the court decide in Société des Produits Nestlé S.A v Cadbury UK?
The judge held that a single colour can be a valid sign capable of graphical representation, following established European case law on this point. Describing the colour as the "predominant" colour of the packaging didn't turn the mark into some vague, open-ended combination of colours, so Nestlé's main challenge failed. However, the judge found Cadbury's evidence of distinctiveness only supported the colour purple as identifying milk chocolate, not chocolate generally. The registration was narrowed accordingly, while the separate term "chocolate for eating" was found clear enough to stand.
What we learned from this
- What I'd take from this is that winning the principle doesn't mean winning the whole case. Cadbury kept the right to register a colour as a trademark, but still had the scope of its protection cut back because its evidence didn't stretch that far.
- If you're claiming a trademark covers a colour, shape or other non-traditional sign, make sure your evidence of distinctiveness matches the full list of goods or services you're claiming, not just part of it.
- A broad specification sounds attractive but a court will narrow it to whatever your evidence actually proves, so it's worth checking the evidence before filing the application.
- This judgment wasn't the end of the story. The same dispute kept being appealed and relitigated for years, which shows how costly and drawn out colour mark disputes can become.
Things to be aware of
- This 2012 High Court decision was later overtaken by the Court of Appeal in 2013, which found Cadbury's mark description too uncertain to be validly registered at all.
- The wider dispute over this purple colour mark continued for roughly another decade, including further High Court proceedings and a settlement between the parties.
- The ruling on the sign and the ruling on the specification both matter here, winning one point didn't mean Cadbury's registration survived unchanged.
The businesses involved
Société des Produits Nestlé S.A
The intellectual property holding arm of the Nestlé group, which owns and manages trademarks used across Nestlé's confectionery and food businesses, including rival chocolate brands to Cadbury.
- Note
- Registered outside the UK
Cadbury UK Limited
Registered in England in 1919 and still active, classified under manufacture of cocoa and chocolate confectionery. Based in Birmingham and holds a large portfolio of marks on the UK trademark register.
- Companies House
- 00155256 Active
- Incorporated
- May 1919
- Registered office
- Birmingham
- Business activity
- Manufacture of cocoa and chocolate confectionery
- UK trademarks
- 958
What happened next
- Nestlé went on to appeal this ruling, and the Court of Appeal in 2013 held that Cadbury's colour mark description was not sufficiently precise to be validly registered.Source: Wipo
- The broader rivalry between the two companies continued in parallel through separate litigation over Nestlé's KitKat shape mark, in which Cadbury's opposition succeeded at the High Court.Source: Confectionery News, April 2016
- The High Court later delivered a further judgment in 2022 that was described as partially favourable to Cadbury in the long-running purple colour dispute.Source: IPKat, July 2022
- The companies reached a settlement at one stage of the prolonged litigation before further High Court consideration of the colour mark took place.Source: IP Iustitia, October 2022
What others said about it
- Wolters Kluwer's coverage describes the dispute as having 'recommenced' at a later High Court stage, underlining how this fight kept returning to court over many years.Source: Wolters Kluwer, November 2022
- Lexology's write-up frames Cadbury's path to registering the colour purple as a story of persistence through repeated legal setbacks.Source: Lexology, October 2022
How we can help
If something in this case sounds familiar, talk it through with us. The first call is free for new clients.
This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Summary drafted with AI assistance from the published judgment and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Judgment: [2012] EWHC 2637 (Ch) on Find Case Law, published under the Open Justice Licence. Company details from Companies House; trademark counts from the UK trademark register. Last reviewed 4 November 2026. Report an error.










