Nestlé v Mars UK: “Have A Break” fails as a standalone trademark
SOCIÉTÉ DES PRODUITS NESTLÉ S.AvMARS UK
- Court
- Court of Appeal
- Judgment
- 25 July 2003
- Citation
- [2003] EWCA Civ 1072
Carving a short phrase out of a longer slogan doesn't automatically make that phrase a protectable trademark.
Nestlé tried to register "Have A Break" on its own as a trademark for chocolate, separate from its famous "Have A Break...Have A Kit Kat" slogan. The Court of Appeal agreed with Mars UK that the phrase alone lacked distinctive character.
What happened
Nestlé applied in 1995 to register "Have A Break" by itself as a trademark for chocolate products. It had used the longer slogan "Have a break...Have a Kit Kat" for years, but this application was for the shorter phrase alone. Mars UK opposed the application. The Hearing Officer refused registration, finding the phrase was devoid of distinctive character on its own, and that whatever reputation it had came from the full slogan, not from "Have A Break" used by itself. Nestlé appealed to the High Court, lost, and took the case to the Court of Appeal.

What did the court decide in SOCIÉTÉ DES PRODUITS NESTLÉ S.A v MARS UK?
The Court of Appeal agreed that "Have A Break" was devoid of inherent distinctive character under section 3(1)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1994. It rejected Nestlé's argument that because the phrase wasn't purely descriptive under section 3(1)(c), it couldn't fail the separate distinctiveness test under section 3(1)(b). These are different questions and a phrase can fail one without necessarily failing the other. On the harder question, whether Nestlé's long use of the phrase as part of the bigger slogan could count as the shorter phrase acquiring distinctiveness in its own right, the court found genuine uncertainty in the law and referred that question to the European Court of Justice rather than deciding it itself.
What we learned from this
- What I'd take from this is that pulling a short, punchy phrase out of a longer slogan and trying to register it on its own is a harder task than it looks, even if the full slogan is genuinely famous.
- A name, logo or tagline needs to work as a badge of origin by itself. Being part of something well known isn't automatically the same thing.
- Don't assume that failing one legal test for distinctiveness (being too descriptive) means you automatically pass a different test (having no distinctive character at all). They're separate hurdles.
- If your mark relies on use alongside another mark to build up recognition, think carefully about whether that use actually shows consumers rely on the shorter phrase alone.
Things to be aware of
- This judgment didn't finally resolve the acquired distinctiveness question; the Court of Appeal referred it to the European Court of Justice rather than deciding it, so the full answer sits in a later ruling.
The businesses involved
SOCIÉTÉ DES PRODUITS NESTLÉ S.A
Subsidiary of the Nestlé group that holds the group's trademark registrations, including those connected to the Kit Kat brand and its slogans.
- Note
- Registered outside the UK
MARS UK LIMITED
Mars UK opposed Nestlé's attempt to register HAVE A BREAK as a standalone trademark for chocolate products.
What happened next
- World Trademark Review later reported on a separate Nestlé v Mars Court of Appeal dispute, this time over an attempt to register the shape of a Polo mint, where the court again upheld a refusal.Source: Worldtrademarkreview
What others said about it
- 5RB's case report tracks the matter through to the ECJ's 2005 ruling, treating the Court of Appeal decision as the staging point for the referral to the European Court of Justice rather than the final word.Source: 5Rb, July 2005
- Studocu's case study frames the dispute as a useful illustration of the distinct legal tests for registering a slogan as a trademark.Source: Studocu
How we can help
If something in this case sounds familiar, talk it through with us. The first call is free for new clients.
This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Summary drafted with AI assistance from the published judgment and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Judgment: [2003] EWCA Civ 1072 on Find Case Law, published under the Open Justice Licence. Company details from Companies House; trademark counts from the UK trademark register. Last reviewed 4 November 2026. Report an error.










