Established Representative at the UK Intellectual Property Office — since 2008New scam warning · 12 Nov: RL Law Trademark Notice: A New Law Firm’s Nam…

Nestlé v Cadbury: why Cadbury’s purple colour trademark was refused

Jonathan Paton
Jonathan Paton, Founder & CEO4 min read · Last reviewed 4 November 2026
Key factsClaimant won

Société Des Produits Nestlé S.AvCadbury UK

Court
Court of Appeal
Judgment
4 October 2013
Citation
[2013] EWCA Civ 1174
The lesson

A colour trademark description has to describe one fixed sign, not a range of possible looks.

View the full case fileThe judgment, documents and timeline, with a free Temmy Portal login

Cadbury wanted to register its specific shade of purple as a trademark for chocolate. The Court of Appeal sided with Nestlé and said the description Cadbury used was too loose to count as one single sign.

What happened

In 2004 Cadbury applied to register a specific shade of purple, Pantone 2685C, as a trademark for chocolate. The description said the colour was applied to the whole visible surface of the packaging "or being the predominant colour" on that surface. Both the UK Intellectual Property Office's Hearing Officer and the High Court accepted the application, finding the colour was distinctive enough for shoppers to recognise. Nestlé opposed the registration and appealed, arguing that the wording did not describe one single sign that could be represented clearly enough on the register.

Temmy the owl reading

What did the court decide in Société Des Produits Nestlé S.A v Cadbury UK?

The Court of Appeal allowed Nestlé's appeal. It held that the word "predominant" in Cadbury's description meant the mark could cover many different visual presentations, with other undefined colours and materials appearing alongside the purple. That did not meet the legal requirement, under Article 2 of the Trademarks Directive, for a sign to be represented graphically with clarity, precision and objectivity. The court also declined to send the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union, saying existing case law on colour marks already gave enough guidance to decide the point.

What we learned from this

  • What I'd take from this is that wording matters as much as the colour itself. Cadbury had a genuinely distinctive colour, but the way it described the mark let in too many possible looks for the register to pin down.
  • When applying for a colour trademark, describe it as a fixed, self-contained sign rather than leaving room for it to appear alongside other unspecified colours or materials.
  • Words like 'predominant' or 'primarily' in a trademark description can turn one sign into an open-ended range, which registries and courts are likely to find too vague.
  • Winning at first instance doesn't settle the question. Cadbury succeeded before the Hearing Officer and the High Court, then lost on appeal, so the description needs to hold up at every stage.

Things to be aware of

  • This case is about the description used in the application, not whether purple itself could ever be protected for chocolate.
  • The ruling doesn't say colours can never be registered as trademarks, only that the sign applied for has to be precise and fixed.
  • Cadbury's wider fight over the purple colour mark didn't end here. Later proceedings, including a 2022 High Court judgment, gave Cadbury some success with a differently worded application.

The businesses involved

Claimant

Société Des Produits Nestlé S.A

Nestlé group company that holds Nestlé's trademark rights and opposed Cadbury's purple colour mark application, including as it competes with Cadbury through its KitKat brand.

Note
Registered outside the UK
Defendant

Cadbury UK Limited

Registered in England since 1919 and still active, Cadbury UK Limited is a chocolate confectionery manufacturer based in Birmingham, holding 958 trademarks on the UK trademark register and long associated with purple packaging.

Companies House
00155256 Active
Incorporated
May 1919
Registered office
Birmingham
Business activity
Manufacture of cocoa and chocolate confectionery
UK trademarks
958

What happened next

  • The dispute over Cadbury's purple colour mark did not end with this ruling. A later High Court judgment in 2022 partially allowed renewed applications by Cadbury.Source: IPKat, July 2022
  • The 2022 High Court ruling was reported as giving Cadbury some relief in its long-running effort to secure protection for its purple colouring.Source: Wolters Kluwer, November 2022
  • Commentary described Cadbury's eventual partial success in 2022 as the result of a sustained, multi-year pursuit of registration for the purple colour mark.Source: Lexology, October 2022
  • The 2022 High Court consideration of Cadbury's colour mark was reported as following a settlement reached between Cadbury and Nestlé.Source: IP Iustitia, October 2022

How we can help

If something in this case sounds familiar, talk it through with us. The first call is free for new clients.

This page is for information purposes only and does not constitute trademark advice or guidance. Summary drafted with AI assistance from the published judgment and checked by The Trademark Helpline (how we write these). Judgment: [2013] EWCA Civ 1174 on Find Case Law, published under the Open Justice Licence. Company details from Companies House; trademark counts from the UK trademark register. Last reviewed 4 November 2026. Report an error.

Trusted by businesses across the UK & beyond
Latest from The Trademark HelplineKnowledge Hub
Temmy the owl with a question

Book your free 15-minute callChoose a day and time and a specialist will call you.

or call 0161 833 5400

Download Your Guide

Fill in the form below to access your free guide.